MN Fishing Intel™

Minnesota lakes. Better-informed fishing.

Size-qualified survey comparison worksheet

More fish in a survey does not necessarily mean more fish at your preferred size. Compare a catch-rate index with the fraction of measured fish that meet the same size preference.

Educational example—not a lake recommendation. The starting inputs are fictional, not Minnesota survey observations. This illustrates size-qualified abundance, not the separate Keeper-limit opportunity model, legal limits or an angler's expected catches per hour.

Use the same species, size definition and comparable survey method for both rows. Survey catch rate means fish per unit of survey effort, not fish per hour of recreational fishing. The formula is survey catch rate × qualifying measured fish ÷ all measured fish. A measured subset that poorly represents the survey can make the comparison misleading.

Example A
Example B
Reset to fictional examples

Your comparison

Calculated size-qualified indices, not legal harvest limits
ExampleSurvey catch rateQualifying shareSize-qualified index
A1020.0%2.000
B650.0%3.000

Example B has the higher size-qualified index for these inputs. That does not establish better access, newer evidence, higher confidence or a better trip.

How to interpret the default example

A has a survey catch rate of 10 and 8 qualifying fish out of 40 measured: 10 × 0.20 = 2. B has a lower catch rate of 6 but 20 qualifying fish out of 40: 6 × 0.50 = 3. B ranks higher on this one calculation even though A's total catch rate is larger. Change B's qualifying count to 10 and its index becomes 1.5, so the order reverses.

What this leaves out

The worksheet does not account for survey age, gear selectivity, seasonal conditions, uncertainty, regulation changes or access. Zero qualifying fish returns zero; zero measured fish is rejected because a size share cannot be calculated from no measurements. A large measured sample does not automatically mean that different gear or different species are comparable.

Only these numeric inputs are used; the worksheet does not ask for your location or account and does not save inputs into your Journal. Submitted values appear in the page address: do not enter sensitive information. Read how production rankings differ or try Lake Rankings.